thomas_miller5

Asked 7 years ago
 
What is everyones Favorite War movie from the last 60 years?
[archived]
Now it doesn't matter if its a sci fi alien style movie or not. I came up with this one after seeing the newest Green Day video for "Wake me up when September Ends" and would like to know what everyones opinion is.

Mine would have to be Black Hawk Down mainly because it is the one that I can say was one that I was around for. My fourth grade english teacher had a son in that one and I remember its about what it was like. Then when I saw that movie everything the soldeir told me about it came back and a customer at a job I used to have would tell me about it and it is just scary that there are people out there with that much hate that could do even a way more then even what the movie showed.

Anyway what is your opinions?
 
Category: forum
 
38
answers
 
13080
views

Answers

Click here to view all answers for above question


dispenser

Answered 7 years ago
 
Great movies that occurred during war but didn't show actual battle include The Bridge on the River Kwai

Weren't bullets exchanged near some bridge? ;-)

Of course this is a big generalisation but Americans can't make believable movies about WWII. I think that Europeans know better what a war is like. Of course American soldiers know that, but in this continent everyone had to face the war, not only soldiers. We had to rebuild our countries etc, it affected Europe much more.

Are you saying that in order to make a "believable" war movie, you have to include (or even focus on) the civilian impact? If so, that's more of a matter of taste than a criticism. That'd be like saying a WWII movie is unbelievable because it didn't focus on the political leaders of the day.

However, if a movie is trying to show the civilian impact and utterly fails to do so convincingly, then that would be a fair criticism. If this is what you meant, I'd like to see which movies you were talking about, not that I doubt you, but just for clarity.
 
0
rating

This question is closed to new answers.